Do You Know What Kind of Editor You Need: A Simple Guide for Indie Authors

Author confused about what type of editor they need

Have you ever thought to yourself, “I know I need to hire an editor, but I don’t know what kind?” If so, you are not alone. There are many different types of editors and most indie authors don’t have a publishing team to help them make these kinds of decisions. I’m here to dispel the confusion. Keep reading to learn which type of editing is right for you based on where you are, right now.

Many new authors don’t realize that editor is an umbrella term that covers many different jobs. Choosing the wrong type of editor (or the right type too early) is a waste of money and energy.

Hire a Developmental Editor if You Need Help With the Big Picture 

Developmental editors focus on:

    • plot, structure, pacing,

    • character arcs and motivation

    • worldbuilding and consistency

    • theme and emotional impact

This might be the editing for you if:

    • something in your story feels off, but you can’t pinpoint what it is

    • early readers are confused

    • you’re revising an early draft and feel stuck on what to focus on

Not all authors will use a developmental editor for every project. This is an in-depth, useful service for new authors, authors who are writing in a new genre, or authors who are generally unsure about the story they are writing.

Hire a Line Editor if You Want Help With Craft, Clarity, Flow

Line editors focuses on:

    • sentence flow and rhythm

    • clarity and readability

    • strengthening/enhancing voice

    • cutting clutter without losing voice

This might be the editing for you if:

    • your story works, but the writing feels clunky

    • readers (or you) stumble over sentences

    • you’re proud of your voice but want it polished

Line editing should make you feel supported and seen. Your editor should truly understand your story and your voice in order to be able to enhance your voice while polishing, rather than replacing it.

Hire a Copyeditor if You Need Technical Accuracy and Consistency

Copyeditors focus on:

    • grammar, spelling, punctuation

    • consistency (names, timeline, capitalization)

    • simple fact checking

    • style guide adherence

You might want copyediting if:

    • the writing is solid

    • you want to reduce errors

    • you’re finished with revisions

Copyediting doesn’t handle anything to do with the story, just the technical aspects of writing.

Hire a Proofreader for Final Checks

Proofreaders focus on:

    • typos and small errors

    • formatting-related issues

    • final polish

You might want proofreading if:

    • your manuscript is fully edited

    • you have had other professional editing

    • you are ready push edit

Proofreading always comes last.

Which Do You Need Right Now?

If you’re still revising your story, and need help deciding what to focus on next, look into developmental editing.

If your story is complete, but the prose is clunky, you probably want line editing.

If your prose is solid, but you want to check your grammar, you want to hire a copyeditor.

If you are ready to push publish, you are ready for proofreading.

So What Now?

If you are still unsure which type of editing you need, you can always reach out to me! I’m always happy to chat story, even if you aren’t planning to hire me. If you would like to work with me, I offer line editing, copyediting, and proofreading from this list!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top